Here’s how the horror movie Antlers compares to the Nick Antosca short story on which it’s based, and the main differences between the two works.
How does the horror movie Bagpipe differ from the short story “The Quiet Boy” on which it is based? Nick Antosca is best known as the creator of horror television shows like Channel zero Y New cherry flavorBut he’s also a fiction writer with a penchant for writing puzzling novels and short stories. Her story “The Quiet Boy,” which tells the story of a teacher who learns that her student keeps a nightmarish secret about her family, caused a sensation among horror literature fans when it was published in Guernica Magazine in 2019.
The tale of Antosca was adapted to the big screen in 2021 with Bagpipe – a supernatural horror film directed by Hostile director Scott Cooper and produced by Guillermo del Toro. Naturally, there are many challenges when it comes to adapting short horror stories into a feature film, especially one like “The Quiet Boy,” which has a 20-minute read. And although Antosca was closely involved in the making of the film (he co-wrote the script and acted as executive producer), there are quite a few differences between “The Quiet Boy” and Bagpipe.
The basic premise of Bagpipe and “The Quiet Boy” are the same; A teacher named Julia who works in a small poverty-stricken town is concerned for the well-being of one of his students, Lucas, and delves into his home life only to discover that his father and brother are possessed by a malevolent spirit and They are undergoing a horrible transformation into bloodthirsty monsters and cannibals. However, the differences between the two are apparent almost immediately. The film not only moves the action from the original story setting from West Virginia to Oregon, but it also makes several significant changes to the characters and plot points.
For example, the way the main character Julia is characterized in Bagpipe and “The Quiet Boy” is very different. In the tale, she is a 23-year-old inexperienced young woman reluctantly sent to her post by Teach For America, while in the film adaptation Julia (played by Keri Russell) is older and returns to her hometown after the recent suicide of his abusive father. to reunite with his brother Paul (Jesse Plemons), a more developed backstory that gives him a connection to Lucas (Jeremy T. Thomas). who suspects that they may also be a victim of abuse. Similarly, Lucas’s father, Frank, is a very different character in the horror movie adaptation. Antosca’s story depicts him as an abusive man and suggests that he willingly conjured the entity that possessed him. In BagpipeFrank (Scott Haze) is more of a doting but unfit father who is infected by a supernatural being that he unknowingly encounters.
Another notable difference is that, while “The Quiet Boy” leaves the nature of the monster it possesses ambiguous, Bagpipe specifically identifies him as an Algonquian mythological creature known as a wendigo, a fact explained in a scene filled with exhibits by the only Native American character, former Sheriff Warren Stokes (Graham Greene). How the movie and the ending of the story are also wildly different. “The Quiet Boy” concludes with a bloody revelation that Julia did not survive her encounter with Lucas’ father and brother, but the film shows Julia killing Frank and her son and making it out alive. There is also a scene during the final moments that suggests that Julia’s brother Paul has been possessed by the wendigo creature itself, leaving the door open for a bit. Bagpipe continuation.