Tuesday, November 29

Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog are brilliant because they break the rules

As the top two video game movies join Netflix, we take a look at why they are the best video game movies in a field of failure.

Video game movies aren’t great. They’ve gotten better recently, which I suppose makes sense: the games have been growing in maturity, taking more cues from blockbuster movies, and in turn, their movie adaptations have been getting better. However, this correlation is not necessarily causal. Assassin’s Creed, one of the most cinematic games out there, has an incredibly nasty adaptation. Uncharted, one of the few games even more cinematic than AC, has had a lukewarm reception since Tom Holland was cast, and the fanfare has continued to fade.

Fortunately, the two best video game movies ever, Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog, have just been added to Netflix. The thing is, none of the games felt particularly suited to the big screen at first. So what’s up?

We all have different opinions, but it’s hard to think of credible rivals for Pikachu and Sonic. In fact, if you Google ‘best video game movies’, the top results that come up are Free Guy, Gamer, Jumanji, Tron, and Wreck-it-Ralph, all of which are about video games but are not actively based on any of them. existing games. By the time you get to an actual video game movie, it’s Lara Croft: Tomb Raider, who’s better than she’s given credit for, but she’s still no match for Detective Pikachu. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within, Doom, Alone in the Dark, and Resident Evil also appear. Fun fact: all of these movies are garbage.

See also  Ubisoft's Six-Year Development Hell Pirate Game Leaks In New Footage

Why are Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog so cool then? Detective Pikachu has a decent enough story, but it’s not the pinnacle of video game narrative, and Sonic’s lore is just a series of words about gems and space. However, both films are spectacular. Perhaps there is a sense of causality after all. Not because blockbuster games have adapted well to the screen, but because by making blockbuster games, video games have convinced the movie world to take them seriously. Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog were the first to enter the ground floor.

Away from these two, the tide seems to be turning. Mortal Kombat 2021 was a significant upgrade from the original movie, while The Last of Us TV series seems to be taking shape with the little glimpses we’ve seen so far. Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City also seems to have a better understanding of games and generally just doesn’t suck like the Jovovich movies, while even Werewolves Within was pretty decent for what it was, gaining an impressive 85 percent on. Rotten Tomatoes: the highest score for a video game movie. Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog rank second and third, respectively.

Detective Pikachu works because it’s not actually a video game movie, it’s a good family movie that has Pokémon. Take more cues from something like Despicable Me, or a PG Deadpool, than Lara Croft: Tomb Raider. It’s not trying to be Detective Pikachu, it’s trying to be a decent movie with lovable characters that happen to be Pokémon and it’s aimed at people of all ages. Similarly, Sonic practically makes no attempt to explain Sonic lore, because it doesn’t make sense and even Sonic fans are exhausted by it. The movie simply understands that Sonic is a selling point. Make it fun, do it fast, and you’ve made a movie. That is what they have done.

See also  Real Cats Also Love Stray, The Cyberpunk Cat Game

It seems that this trend will continue as well. While we haven’t seen anything from Super Mario or Borderlands, each boasts an impressive cast, plus Chris Pratt as Mario, and it gives us reason to be hopeful. There are still outliers – Monster Hunter follows in the footsteps of the old Resi movies and Uncharted doesn’t look very good, but overall, video game movies seem to be decent now. In the next few years, even better ones will emerge, but for now, Detective Pikachu and Sonic the Hedgehog are the best we have. If you’ve missed them because video game movies suck, give them a try when they hit Netflix this month. You may be pleasantly surprised.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *